I would like to take a look at the reviews for The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins. All
of the reviews were found on the Barnes and Noble website, but they all come
from different sources. The Hunger Games
is about a post-apocalyptic World in the future where the main character,
Katniss, is forced to compete in the Hunger Games. The Hunger Games is an event
established by the dictatorship they all live under where one boy and one girl
are chosen from each district (there are 12 districts) and they are forced to
go into an arena and fight to the death. Katniss chooses to take her sister’s
place in the games, by volunteering. She and a boy from her district, Peeta, go
to the arena to fight all other 22 tributes to the death. The Hunger Games are
a widely popular television show throughout Panem (the country).
One review for The
Hunger Games is found in Publishers Weekly and was written by Megan Whalen
Turner. The direction she decides to take with the review is a plot summary
first. She spends two paragraphs with plot summary, and then decides to analyze
some key things about the book. She starts off by analyzing why the Hunger
games were a televised event. She says that the fear of reality television is
the fear of our generation. The fears of other generations were runaway
science, communism, overpopulation, and nuclear wars. She thinks our main fear
today is reality television. I do not think I agree with this. She may have
just said this for the purpose of her review, I cannot think of any other
reason. We have many other things to fear today, like global warming or
terrorism. I think that is what defines the fears of our generation, not
reality television. I have never even heard of that being a legitimate fear of
this generation.
She proceeds to talk about how this World Collins creates
could become a reality and we need to watch out for that. I do not agree with
that either. I think the purpose of Collins writing these books was to protest
war. Her father was either in a war or a protester of war, and taught Collins about
peace and resistance to war. That is what I think these books were really
about. I do not think we need to worry about our society becoming like the one
in the book any time soon.
I think that this book review was interesting. She was
definitely voicing her own opinions and not really considering many others. She
had a good flow from topic to topic, and her word choice was eloquent, but I do
not agree with her review. I think it is interesting how different her
interpretation of the book can be to mine. I think that means the book could
mean many different things to many different people. I wish she would have
talked more about the actual book than the fear of reality television.
I think that people who review are likely to bring up issues that may not actually exist in the book. The might do this just to get their views out in a way that connects them to a popular work (Hunger Games).
ReplyDelete